Reviewed by: Jay. D

Expert Contributor: Maya Transoloski

There’s a reason the best water rowing machines have become so popular, and that’s simply because they offer something a little different from other types of rowing machines.

Just think of what a water rowing machine can offer. You have that rowing on water feel from the dynamic resistance system, you can hear the blades pushing water around the tank, and throw in a decent app with a scenic rowing route, and you’ll almost feel like you’re right there on the water.

More Than Just the Rowing Experience

And it’s not just the immersive experience you get from a water rower that sells them to me.

The solid oak water rowers are nice and heavy, sturdy machines, and I love their low profile design. It really helps keep them planted on the floor, even when rowing hard. And let’s not forget how good these things look.

So yeah, what I’m getting at here is that water rowers have a lot going for them, and it’s not just about the resistance system.

You don’t have to spend over $1,000 to enjoy the benefits of a water rower. Of course, the high end machines come with some amazing apps and a more heavy duty build, and we’ll get into those later.

But if you’re on a tighter budget and looking for something a little more basic but well made, there are some excellent solid wood and steel frame water rowers out there right now for under $500.

waterower original in home showing app

Why Trust Jays Home Gym?

Jay, Founder of JaysHomeGym, has over 25 years of strength training experience and more than 10 years reviewing home fitness equipment. For this guide, rowing machines were compared based on build quality, resistance type, comfort, features, storage options, warranty coverage, ease of use, and overall value for money.

Our goal is simple: to help you find the best rowing machine for your home gym, fitness goals, and budget.

Something for Every Budget

And yes, we’re going to include some really impressive budget rowers in this guide, as well as my favorite high-end water rowers. Because there’s a lot to like at both ends of the market, and it really comes down to what you’re looking for and how much you want to spend.

I’ve reviewed enough rowing machines over the years to know what makes a good one and what doesn’t. And believe me, spending more doesn’t always mean you’re getting a better rower for your needs.

Some of the high-end machines are seriously impressive, especially when it comes to build quality and workout tech. But I’ve also been surprised by just how good some of the cheaper water rowers have become.

So yeah, we’ve narrowed it down to five of our favorites, each picked for a different reason. Let’s take a look.

At a Glance: Our 5 Top Picks

  • Best Water Rowing Machine Overall: WaterRower Original S4 – Solid oak, superb engineering, and a lovely natural rowing feel. Sometimes simple really is best.
  • Best Budget Water Rowing Machine: MERACH R28 – A surprisingly well-made wooden water rower for under $300, with a free rowing app too.
  • Best Interactive Water Rowing Machine: Ergatta Luxe – Premium WaterRower build quality meets addictive gaming workouts. Perfect if you love a bit of competition.
  • Best Steel-Frame Water Rowing Machine: Sunny Obsidian Surge 500
  • Best Compact Water Rowing Machine: JOROTO MR280PRO – A shorter, sturdy water rower that’s ideal when workout space is limited.

Compare Our 5 Best Water Rowing Machines

So, which of these five rowers is right for you? Let’s compare the key specs side by side, then we’ll take a closer look at what makes each one special.

WaterRower Original Rowing Machine
Best Overall
Merach R28 Water Rowing Machine
Best Budget
Ergatta Luxe Water Rowing Machine
Best Interactive
Sunny Obsidian Surge Water Rower
Best Steel Frame
Joroto MR280Pro Water Rower
Best Compact
waterrower original s4
Merach r28 waterrowing machine
ergatta luxe water rower
sunny obsidian surge water rower
Joroto water rower mr280
Rating
4.7/5
4.4/5
4.7/5
4.3/5
4.3/5
Price
$1299.99
$189.57
$2299.00
$449.99
$299.99
Weight
67lb
50.2lb
78lb
91lb
52.2lb
Resistance type
Dynamic
Dynamic
Dynamic
Dynamic
Dynamic
Storage
Vertical
180° folding, upright
Vertical
Vertical
180° folding
Screen
S4 Performance Monitor
LED digital monitor
21" HD touchscreen
R2 Fitness Meter (LCD)
LCD monitor
App/connectivity
WaterRower Connect + Bluetooth
MERACH App + Kinomap, Bluetooth
Ergatta App, Wi-Fi + Bluetooth
Sunny Fit
Kinomap + Bluetooth
Best for
Anyone who wants premium build quality and a natural rowing feel
Beginners who want a quality water rower without spending a fortune
Rowers who love gaming and competition
Rowers who prefer a sturdy steel frame
Rowers with limited workout space
Demo Image

Reviews

Okay, let’s get into the rowers. We’ve done the digging, narrowed down the choices, and picked five water rowers we think deserve a place on this list. From surprisingly good budget machines to beautifully engineered wooden rowers and high-end gaming models, there’s something here for everyone.

Best Water Rowing Machine Overall

back view waterrower original

WaterRower Original S4

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.7/5)

JHG Score

Specs

  • Price: $1299.99
  • Product dimensions: 87.75″D x 22.25″W x 20″H
  • Product weight: 67.2lb
  • Storage: vertical
  • Resistance levels: dynamic
  • Max user height: 6’6″
  • Weight Limit: 330lb/700lb

The Good

Solid oak frame, and this thing is built to last

One of the few water rowers that’s genuinely stood the test of time

Smooth dynamic resistance gives you a very natural rowing feel

Long dual rails, so taller users should be fine

S4 monitor might look dated, but it gives you all the important rowing stats

Built-in Bluetooth with WaterRower Connect and plenty of app options

– Stores upright and looks good enough to leave on display

The Bad

Expensive at over $1,000

S4 monitor looks dated compared with newer displays

WaterRower Connect Premium costs extra, although it’s only $4.99/month

Budget solid wood rowers now offer many of the same basic features for considerably less

Why We Like It

WaterRower is a company with decades of experience building some of the best solid wood rowers on the market. These guys know what they’re doing, and they do it well. And that’s the first real selling point of the WaterRower Original: it’s a machine that’s stood the test of time.

People are still praising their WaterRowers years after buying them, and there aren’t many rowing machines around with that kind of feedback.

And the reason the WaterRower Original gets so much praise is its build quality. This thing is built from solid oak and weighs nearly 70 lb dry. That’s a heavy rower, and that weight gives it a premium feel you just don’t get with cheaper, lightweight water rowers.

It’s the little touches, too, like the eight ball bearing seat rollers that glide smoothly along the long dual rails, the ergonomically designed seat, and its simple yet beautiful design that set the WaterRower apart.

Almost everything about this rower shouts premium, and it looks amazing too. Yes, it’s expensive for a machine without a large HD screen, but you’re paying for the build quality. This is a rower built to last for years, and it’s just as well suited to a commercial gym as it is to your home.

So yeah, while the tech might not be quite as impressive as some other high end rowers, the build quality is second to none, and that’s what matters most.

And even though the S4 monitor looks fairly basic, it’s actually pretty good, tracking all the essential workout data, including split times. It’s Bluetooth-enabled too, so if you want even more from your workouts, just grab a tablet and download WaterRower’s excellent Connect app.

Read our full WaterRower S4 Review

—————————————————-

Best Budget Water Rowing Machine

side view merach water rowing machine

Merach R28 Water Rower

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.4/5)

JHG Score

Specs

  • Price: $279.99
  • Product dimensions: 60″D x 18″W x 30″H
  • Product weight: 50.2lb
  • Storage: upright/folding
  • Resistance levels: dynamic
  • Max user height: 6’6″
  • Weight Limit: 400lb

The Good

51lb build feels reassuringly solid for a rower under $300

Smooth water resistance that naturally gets tougher the harder you row

Long dual rail gives taller users plenty of room for a full rowing stroke

Excellent folding design makes it surprisingly easy to store

Free Merach app adds classes, workouts and a bit of fun without a subscription

The Bad

Seat sits quite low, which could make getting on and off awkward for some

Stronger rowers may want more resistance at the top end

Monitor is still fairly basic, even though the Bluetooth and free app make up for it

Why We Like It

Just a few years ago, you couldn’t get hold of a decent budget solid wood water rower for under $600. But fast forward a few years, and companies like Merach are producing very well made solid wood rowers for under $300. And this isn’t a cheaply made rower either.

The Merach R28 weighs over 50 lb. It’s over 10 lb heavier than other sub-$300 water rowers. It’s a solid, sturdy machine that could easily be mistaken for something much more expensive.

And that’s just why I like the R28 so much. Merach has somehow managed to get all the essentials right with this rower and keep the price under $300.

The quality is high. Okay, not to the level of something like the WaterRower Original, but high enough that it almost has that premium feel.

The rowing stroke is smooth, the seat gives enough support even when rowing hard, and the app is excellent for a free app. It even includes workouts, scenic routes and a lot more. You really do get a lot of rower for your money with this one.

When I first reviewed this water rower, I honestly couldn’t find much fault with it. I was that impressed, and years on from then, I still can’t. It’s by far the best budget solid wood rower on the market, and it’s easy to understand why it receives such high praise from its owners.

Read our full Merach R28 Review

—————————————————-

Best Interactive Water Rowing Machine

ergatta rower app

Ergatta Luxe Water Rower

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.7/5)

JHG Score

Specs

  • Price: $2199.99
  • Product dimensions: 81.8″D x 18.9″W x 23.6″H
  • Product weight: 73.2lb
  • Storage: vertical
  • Resistance levels: dynamic
  • Max user height: 6’7″
  • Weight Limit: 500lb

The Good

Built by WaterRower, so you know the engineering is going to be good.

Solid cherrywood frame. This thing is seriously well made

That huge 21.5-inch HD touchscreen is a real treat

Games, races and challenges make rowing a lot less boring

Smooth water resistance, with plenty of challenge for experienced rowers

Strong, stable dual-rail design, and it stores upright too.

The Bad

That $2,000-plus price tag is going to put a lot of people off

Another $39 a month for the full Ergatta experience

– Low seat height won’t suit everyone, especially anyone with mobility issues

Why We Like It

I’ve always liked the idea of making cardio workouts a little more fun, and that’s exactly what Ergatta has done with its Luxe rower.

Instead of staring at workout numbers for half an hour, you’re racing other rowers, chasing personal bests, and playing games that actually make you want to push harder. And I think that’s a big selling point, especially if you’re someone who struggles to stay motivated with cardio.

And the first thing that grabs your attention is that awesome 21.5-inch HD touchscreen. It’s large, bright, and makes the whole workout experience feel much more immersive.

Whether you’re racing against other rowers, working your way through one of Ergatta’s gaming challenges, or enjoying a scenic row, there’s always something interesting happening on that screen. It’s the sort of setup that can make you forget you’re actually doing a pretty tough workout.

I also like how the workouts adapt to your fitness level. You’re not just following the same old routines. The system learns what you’re capable of and adjusts the challenges as you improve, so there’s always something to aim for.

And with so many different games, races and workouts to choose from, I can’t see many people getting bored with this one.

But it’s not just the gaming that impresses me. The Ergatta Luxe is built by WaterRower in the USA, so you’re getting that beautiful solid cherrywood frame, a smooth, natural rowing stroke, and the same excellent engineering that makes WaterRower machines so good.

This is a seriously well-made rower, and it looks amazing too.

Okay, it’s expensive, and you’ll need the $39 monthly membership to get the best out of the gaming features. But you’re getting WaterRower’s superb build quality combined with one of the most enjoyable interactive workout systems around. And if a bit of competition, some great looking scenery and a huge screen are what get you rowing more often, I think the Ergatta Luxe is going to be very hard to beat.

Read our full Ergatta Luxe Review

—————————————————-

Best Steel Frame Water Rowing Machine Review

side view sunny obsidian surge 500

Sunny Obsidian Surge 500 Water Rower

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.3/5)

JHG Score

Specs

  • Price: $449.99
  • Product dimensions: 81.8″D x 18.9″W x 23.6″H
  • Product weight: 81.2lb
  • Storage: Vertical
  • Resistance levels: Dynamic
  • Max user height: Around 6’6″
  • Weight Limit: 300lb

The Good

Solid 81lb build that feels seriously sturdy

Smooth dynamic water resistance

Excellent free SunnyFit app with tons of workouts

Impressive monitor with 500m split and wireless heart rate monitoring

17″ seat makes getting on and off much easier

Vertical storage saves a ton of space

The Bad

Heart rate chest strap isn’t included

At 81lb, it’s not a rower you’ll want to carry around

The design looks a little dated next to the newer wooden rowers

Why We Like It

Sunny has always been one of my go-to companies when recommending high-quality fitness equipment on a budget. These guys have been around for years. I first started reviewing their gear over 10 years ago, and I’ve always been impressed with what Sunny offers for the money. Bang for your buck, these are the guys to go to.

The Obsidian Surge is their flagship water rower, and it deserves to be. This rower is a beast. Weighing 88 lb, it’s heavy and solid. All that weight helps keep it firmly planted on the floor, and even when rowing hard, the Obsidian feels sturdy.

Steel-frame rowers don’t quite have the looks of solid wood rowers, but they’re just as good, especially a heavy-duty machine like the Sunny.

And they’ve got all the essentials right too. The rowing stroke is nice and smooth, the seat glides effortlessly along the long rail, and the seat height is great too. It’s not as low as the wooden rowers, which I prefer.

Okay, the tech is a little dated, but the monitor really is a decent one. It tracks all your essential workout data and even includes the 500 m split, something I always like to see on a rowing machine.

And Sunny has kept the price down too. At just under $500 for a heavy-duty steel-frame rower, it offers excellent value for money. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned rower, the Sunny is a great choice. It might not have the beautiful looks of a solid oak rower, but it’s still a good-looking, heavy-duty machine with plenty going for it. And for the money, I think it’s an excellent buy.

Read our full Sunny Obsidian Surge Review

—————————————————-

Best Compact Water Rowing Machine

side view Joroto water rowing machine

Joroto Water Rowing Machine

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.3/5)

JHG Score

Specs

  • Price: $299.99
  • Product dimensions: 70.9″D x 17.5″W x 21.7″H
  • Product weight: 52.2lb (water tank empty)
  • Storage: Folding
  • Resistance levels: dynamic
  • Max user height: up to 6’5″
  • Weight Limit: 400lb

The Good

Solid oak frame feels a cut above the price point

Smooth, quiet water resistance and belt drive

Excellent 180° folding design, no need to empty the tank

39″ inseam gives taller users plenty of room

Bluetooth plus plenty of free workouts through the JOROTO app

The Bad

Basic monitor isn’t anything to get excited about

Foot straps could be better and may need retightening during longer rows

At 52 lb dry, it’s not as heavy-duty as premium wooden rowers

Why We Like It

There’s a lot to like about the JOROTO MR280PRO, and what impressed me most was just how much rower they’ve managed to squeeze into such a compact design. This thing is built from solid oak, weighs over 50 lb, and has a sturdy feel you wouldn’t normally expect from a water rower costing under $200.

And I particularly like those long dual rails. Most compact rowing machines sacrifice rail length to save space, but JOROTO has managed to keep a decent rowing length without making the machine unnecessarily bulky. That’s a big plus, especially if you’re a taller rower who doesn’t want a huge machine taking over the room.

The rowing stroke is nice and smooth, the seat feels supportive, and the extra weight helps keep everything stable when you’re rowing hard. They’ve got the essentials right, and that’s always the first thing I look for.

You also get Bluetooth and the JOROTO app, which is a nice bonus at this price. There’s more to this rower than just a basic monitor, and I like that JOROTO hasn’t forgotten about the workout tech while keeping costs down.

So yeah, the MR280PRO was one of our favorites right from the start. It’s well-built, looks great, folds away when you’re finished, and doesn’t cost a fortune. If you’re short on space but still want a proper wooden water rower, this is one I’d seriously consider.

Read our full Joroto MR280PRO Review

—————————————————-

Water Rowing Machine Buying Guide

If this is your first time purchasing a water rower, it’s always best to do a little research first so you know exactly what to look for. I’ve put together a quick buyer’s guide that should help you choose the right water rower for your needs and explain a little more about these impressive machines.

Are Water Rowers Complicated to Set Up and Use?

It’s a myth that water rowers are any more complicated to set up and use than other rowing machines. There’s nothing particularly difficult about a water rower compared with an air rower you may have used at your local gym.

Most water rowers arrive partially assembled. The complicated stuff, like the drive system and water tank, is usually already fitted. You’ll generally need to attach the rails, seat, stabilizers, footrests and monitor, depending on the model.

Assembly often takes around 30–60 minutes, although some machines take a little longer. Then all that’s left is to fill the water tank.

woman using a water rower in a gym

Filling the Water Tank

Most water rowers come with water-level markings on their tanks. Some have six levels, while others use a different system.

You can think of adding more water as increasing the weight of the boat you’re rowing. The more water in the tank, the heavier the rowing stroke feels.

Most people find a moderate water level provides a good starting point, but it’s best to follow the manufacturer’s recommended fill levels rather than guessing.

And remember, it’s the pace of your workout that primarily determines resistance strength. Adding extra water changes the feel and intensity of the stroke, but rowing faster is what really increases the resistance.
Rowing Machine Weight & Stability
The weight of any piece of cardio equipment is important, as it often gives us a good idea of how sturdy the machine is going to feel. It can also give us a clue about the quality of materials used in the build. Generally, a heavier rower is a good sign, although weight isn’t everything.

The good news is that most water rowers are fairly substantial machines. Some of the high-end models weigh over 80 lb dry, but even budget wooden rowers like the MERACH R28, weighing just over 50 lb, can feel surprisingly sturdy.

And if you’re choosing a solid wood rower, these machines are usually low-profile in design, and that low center of gravity helps with stability.

Other stability features to look for include wide or dual rails, as these help keep the seat stable. Wide stabilizing feet at either end of the rower also help prevent wobbling. And lastly, look for a contoured seat, as this helps stop you from slipping during the push phase of the rowing stroke.

Adjustable levelers are another useful feature for keeping a rower stable on uneven floors. You’ll find these on some steel-frame water rowers, although they’re less common on wooden models.

sunny obsidian surge 500 rowing app

Monitors & Workout Apps

Water rowers used to be fairly basic when it came to workout tech, and many still are. But things have improved quite a bit over the past few years.

Budget and mid-priced water rowers usually come with straightforward LCD monitors that track your essential workout data, such as time, distance, strokes per minute, total strokes and sometimes your 500 m split time.

And that’s enough for most of us.

But we’re also seeing more water rowers with Bluetooth and workout apps, even at the budget end of the market. The MERACH R28 is a good example, offering app-based workouts and scenic routes without an expensive subscription.

At the other end of the market, you’ve got machines like the Ergatta Luxe with its huge 21.5-inch HD touchscreen, interactive games, races and workouts that adapt to your fitness level. It’s a completely different experience from staring at a small LCD screen.

The good thing about a basic monitor is that it takes no time to set up. You can just jump on your rower and get going. And many don’t need a power outlet, so you can use your rower almost anywhere.

So don’t dismiss a water rower just because it has a basic monitor. The rowing machine itself is still the most important thing, and you can always choose a Bluetooth-enabled model if you want more workout options.
Water Rowers: Dynamic Resistance
Water resistance is dynamic, which means the resistance increases the harder and faster you row. You don’t need to stop and turn a resistance knob or select a higher level on the monitor.

This is one of the reasons people love water rowing machines. The resistance responds naturally to your effort, giving you a rowing feel that’s much closer to being out on the water.

Magnetic rowing machines generally use a constant resistance system. The resistance setting stays the same unless you manually change it using a knob or monitor. While magnetic resistance has its advantages, such as being whisper quiet, it doesn’t quite give you that same natural rowing feel.

And that’s one of the biggest selling points of a water rower. Whether you’re taking it easy or pushing hard, the resistance responds to you.

wenoker water rower folding system

Storage

Water rowers are usually fairly large machines, so make sure you measure out enough space to row comfortably before buying one.

Not all of us are lucky enough to have a separate room to keep a rowing machine permanently, so a space-saving design can be a big advantage.

The good news is that many water rowers can be stored vertically, taking up surprisingly little floor space when not in use. Some newer wooden models, including the MERACH R28 and JOROTO MR280PRO, also have folding designs, which makes them particularly useful for smaller homes.

Still, not every water rower can be stored upright or folded, so it’s something you need to check before buying.

And remember to check the ceiling height if you’re planning to store your rower vertically. Some of the longer machines can be quite tall when stood upright.

Final Verdict

For a while, I put off reviewing the WaterRower Original because I thought it was mainly about that beautiful solid oak design. But I’m happy to say I was wrong.

The WaterRower is much more than just looks. This machine is so well made. It’s solid, has that heavy-duty premium feel so many owners mention, and the rowing stroke is smooth. Just about everything about it impressed me.

What’s even more impressive is that when you research WaterRower, you start to realize how much goes into the design and how much care goes into producing these awesome machines.

They’re a company that takes real pride in their work, and it shows.

The WaterRower Original has decades of experience and engineering behind it, and I think the build quality is the best out there. Yes, it’s pretty pricey, but you’re paying for what I consider the best water rowing machine on the market. And it’s built to last.

Still, if you don’t have that sort of cash to spend, there’s no need to despair. Companies like MERACH are producing surprisingly good solid wood rowers at a fraction of the price.

I was taken aback by just how good the MERACH R28 was for the money.

The build quality was impressive, the rowing stroke was smooth, and there really wasn’t much to find fault with. Even the app impressed me, especially for a free one.

Okay, the MERACH R28 isn’t really aimed at more serious rowers, but if you’re someone who wants a decent solid wood water rower for a few sessions a week to improve fitness or lose weight, I highly recommend checking it out. Value for money, this one’s a winner.

The Future of Water Rowers?

And then there’s the Ergatta Luxe. If this is where water rowing machines are heading, I’m all for it! You’ve got that same excellent WaterRower engineering, a beautiful solid cherrywood frame, and a huge 21.5-inch HD touchscreen that brings a whole new experience to rowing.

The interactive games, competitive races, and scenic workouts are seriously impressive.

It’s expensive, yes, but Ergatta has managed to combine some of the best rowing machine engineering around with some awesome workout tech. And I think we’re going to see a lot more of this in the future.

Best Water Rowing Machine FAQ’s

Are water rowing machines better than magnetic rowing machines?

Neither is necessarily better. Water rowers use dynamic resistance, so the harder you row, the more resistance you feel. This gives them a natural rowing feel that many people prefer. Magnetic rowers are generally quieter and often offer more resistance settings and workout programs. It really comes down to personal preference.

Do water rowing machines need much maintenance?

Not much at all. You’ll need to keep the water in the tank clean, usually using the manufacturer’s recommended purification tablets at the specified intervals. It’s also worth wiping down the rails and checking the machine occasionally. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for your particular rower.

Can you change the resistance on a water rowing machine?

Yes, but not in quite the same way as a magnetic rower. The main way to increase resistance is to row harder and faster. You can also adjust the amount of water in the tank within the manufacturer’s recommended limits, which changes how heavy the stroke feels.

Can you store a water rowing machine upright?

Many water rowers can be stored vertically, and some models also fold to save space. However, not every machine supports upright storage, so always check the manufacturer’s instructions. Make sure you’ve got enough ceiling height and follow the recommended storage procedure.